Shareholder Disputes

Shareholder Disputes

As lawyers for shareholder disputes in Munich, we advise and represent shareholders and companies in conflicts within GmbHs and partnerships – out of court and in court.

Rechtsanwalt Marius Siemen und Steuerberater Lukas Conrady in schwarzen Anzügen und weißen Hemden stehen nebeneinander im Freien vor einem modernen Gebäude.Zwei Männer in schwarzen Anzügen mit weißen Hemden und Brillen stehen nebeneinander vor einem modernen Gebäude.

Legal and tax advice in shareholder disputes

Disputes between shareholders usually arise over the company's strategy, profit distribution, management or succession. We advise shareholders on their voting and information rights and on the deadlines to be observed, and represent them in negotiations, in a separation of the shareholders and in litigation. We also review the tax consequences of a settlement, severance payment or share transfer.

Resolutions, information and management

Many shareholder conflicts start with a disputed resolution or a dispute about information or management.

Our services:

  • Challenges to resolutions: Review of shareholder resolutions for formal and substantive defects, and actions for annulment and nullity within the short challenge period
  • Information and inspection: Enforcement of or defence against information and inspection requests under section 51a GmbHG
  • Management: Removal of a managing director under section 38 GmbHG and termination of the service agreement, including review of voting prohibitions
  • Interim relief: Applications for preliminary injunctions, for example against the implementation of a resolution or to secure voting rights

Exit, redemption and separation

If the cooperation cannot be continued, we advise on the terms of the exit and the separation.

Our services:

  • Exclusion and redemption: Review, implementation or defence of a redemption under section 34 GmbHG or an exclusion for good cause
  • Severance: Assessment of severance clauses in the articles and negotiation of amount, instalments and security for the departing shareholder
  • Negotiation and mediation: Negotiations with the other side and, if required, mediation with the aim of reaching a settlement without litigation
  • Separation agreement: Agreements on share transfer, exit and mutual release that settle all disputed claims

Litigation

If proceedings are necessary, we represent shareholders and companies before the regional courts, higher regional courts and arbitral tribunals.

Our services:

  • Action and defence: Representation before regional courts and higher regional courts, at first instance often before the chamber for commercial matters
  • Arbitration: Representation in arbitration proceedings where the articles contain an arbitration clause
  • Conduct of proceedings: Coordination of main proceedings, summary proceedings and parallel settlement negotiations
  • Settlement: Drafting of court and out-of-court settlements, including review of the tax consequences

Tax consequences in shareholder disputes

Severance payments, share transfers and payments to shareholders have tax consequences for both sides.

Our services:

  • Severance for the departing shareholder: Taxation of the capital gain under section 17 Income Tax Act for a shareholding of at least 1%; under the partial income method, 60% is taxable
  • Gift tax for the remaining shareholders: Review of whether a severance payment below the tax value of the share is treated as a gift to the remaining shareholders or the company (section 7 (7) Inheritance Tax Act)
  • Hidden profit distribution: Review of payments to shareholder-managing directors that are challenged as hidden profit distributions in the dispute
  • Severance for the managing director: Reduced tax rate under section 34 Income Tax Act (one-fifth rule) for severance payments, which since 2025 is only applied in the tax assessment
  • Tax loss carryforwards: Review of a forfeiture of losses under section 8c Corporate Income Tax Act where more than 50% of the shares are transferred within five years

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does the initial consultation cost?

Our initial consultation is always free of charge. During this meeting, we will assess your situation and discuss whether and how we can support you moving forward.

How do you calculate the fees for financial accounting, annual financial statements, and tax returns?

We charge a flat fee for these services, which is based on the size and complexity of your business or assets. This ensures that your costs are transparent and clearly defined. We invoice this flat fee on a monthly basis.

How is billing handled for more extensive advisory services (e.g., representation in tax court proceedings or transaction consulting)?

Any additional consulting services are billed at an agreed hourly rate. Before we begin any work, you will receive a cost estimate that requires your approval. This ensures that you are never "surprised" by an invoice.

Can you assist me with international matters?

We would be happy to help. We have a network of consultants for international matters. If you wish, we can handle the coordination, allowing you to keep us as your sole point of contact for all your international activities.

What happens if legal or other questions arise for which you are not the right point of contact?

We have a network of specialized colleagues who can support you with any issue – from business valuation experts to attorneys across all practice areas.

Profilbild von Marius Siemen, Rechtsanwalt und Partner bei Siemen Conrady am Standort München
Marius Siemen
Attorney at law, Partner
Send an email
Profilbild von Lukas Conrady, Steuerberater und Partner bei Siemen Conrady am Standort München
Lukas Conrady
Tax advisor, Partner
Send an email
Contact

Your contacts for shareholder disputes

Please reach out in case you have any questions.

Profilbild von Marius Siemen, Rechtsanwalt und Partner bei Siemen Conrady am Standort München

Marius Siemen

Attorney at law, Partner

Marius Siemen advises on all aspects of German and international tax law. His work focuses in particular on the global investments of institutional investors and private clients across all asset classes. He has extensive experience with projects involving German investors in the United States as well as in the Asia‑Pacific region. Another key area of his practice is the representation of clients in tax disputes: from tax audits to administrative appeals and litigation, as well as the support of clients in criminal tax proceedings.

Profilbild von Lukas Conrady, Steuerberater und Partner bei Siemen Conrady am Standort München

Lukas Conrady

Tax advisor, Partner

Lukas Conrady advises investors, corporations, entrepreneurs, startups, and private clients on matters of national and international taxation. A key focus of his work lies in ongoing tax compliance—particularly the preparation of annual financial statements and tax returns, as well as the support of tax audits, including administrative appeal proceedings. He has in‑depth expertise in M&A, private equity, and real estate transactions, assisting clients with tax due diligence and the tax implementation of subsequent reorganizations. In addition, he advises on the taxation of crypto assets, including the classification and reporting of trading, staking, and lending activities.